Thursday, September 24, 2009

Limiting global warming to not more than 2 degrees C above pre-Industrial Revolution temperatures

Dear W.A. – I read that the European Union wants to limit global warming to maximal 2 degrees above pre-Industrial Revolution temperatures. What does that mean? Signed: Curious.

Dear Curious

Yes, the EU Environment Commissioner has indeed stated that the EU wants to get an agreement at the upcoming UN climate conference in Copenhagen in December to limit global warming to two degrees Celsius, compared with pre-industrial revolution (IR) temperatures. Environmental organizations are saying the same thing. They are obviously not aware that before the IR, the world was in the Little Ice Age. Temperatures were at times about 1.5 degrees Celsius lower than now. The consequences of the Little Ice Age were disastrous. This is well described in Barbara Tuchman’s famous book A Distant Mirror – The Calamitous 14th Century (pages 24-25). Polar and Alpine glaciers advanced. Some villages in the Alps were destroyed by the advancing glaciers. Harvests failed all over Europe, resulting in famines. A weakened population were more prone to diseases, like the plague. There are reports of cannibalism. Norse settlements in Greenland perished. Cultivation of grain disappeared from Iceland and grain harvests in Scandinavia were severely reduced. There were also far more severe storms and floods than in the preceding Medieval Warm Period. For instance, according to the British Professor Lamb, probably as many as 400,000 people perished in the 1570 All Saints Day storm in NW Europe. Two catastrophic storms hit the Netherlands in 1404 and 1421, the so-called “St Elisabeth Floods”, during which tens of thousands of people drowned. It is a myth that man-made global warming will cause more extreme weather events. The opposite is true.

It is obvious that global warming zealots would like the planet to return to those Little Ice Age conditions.

Three points about the 2 degrees maximum dogma:

1. The dogma states that carbon dioxide content in the atmosphere should not rise above 450 ppmv (parts per million by volume) to prevent temperatures rising more that 2 degrees above pre-Industrial Revolution temperatures (others say 350 ppmv). As we have explained above those are Little Ice Age temperatures. However, this dogma is not based on scientific evidence. It is entirely arbitrary. It is mainly based on (non-validated) computer models. As the saying goes rubbish in, gospel out.

2. Carbon dioxide levels in the atmosphere are at present almost the lowest in the entire history of our planet. Plants are starved of carbon dioxide. This is clearly shown by many experiments that show plants thriving under elevated carbon dioxide levels. If carbon dioxide levels would go much lower, say to 200 ppmv, plant growth would stagnate.

3. Global warming advocates are saying that, to reach these 2 degrees and 450 ppmv carbon dioxide aims, we need to reduce carbon dioxide emissions by 80 percent below 1990 levels by 2050. Apart from the fact that such a reduction, if it would be possible at all, would not have the slightest effect on the climate, it would have disastrous effects on the well-being of billions of people. Many of the fantastic and beneficial achievements of the Industrial Revolution will be undone. The man-made-global-warming would like a return to pre-Industrial Revolution conditions. There are now 1.6 billion people without electricity. That number will swell enormously, as electricity is being demonised as contributing to catastrophic global warming (as exemplified by the ludicrous Earth Hour). Replacing coal fired and nuclear power stations with wind turbines and solar panels will lead to severe electricity shortages. Agriculture will have to return to the ox and plow. Transport will be by foot, horse and donkey. Sea travel will be by sailing boats. No more modern medicine. Back to extracting teeth without anaesthetic. Lifespans will decrease to the good old days.

Recently, a major authoritative and definitive answer to the IPCC dogma has been published in the US. It is a hefty 868-page tome from the NIPCC (Nongovernmental International Panel on Climate Change), titled Climate Change Reconsidered, published by the Heartland Institute. It is well-structured and reads easily. Every statement and argument is extensively backed up by referring to peer-reviewed scientific publications. However, I don’t think that this book will have the slightest influence on the present extreme political agendas and manipulations in the lead-up to the UN climate conference in Copenhagen in December. Too many reputations and too many financial interests are at stake.

Therefore, dear Curious, I hope that you are old enough not to have to experience this calamitous future.

Monday, July 20, 2009

Global warming causes sheep in Scotland to shrink


















Dear W.A. - I read in my local newspaper that sheep in Scotland are shrinking because of global warming. I now feel very worried about my pets. I have several. Signed: Worried


Dear Worried - I wouldn’t worry too much. I understand that it is the offspring of animals that are getting smaller because of global warming. You should therefore only worry when you are a pet breeder. Scientists who did the research, published in Science (therefore peer-reviewed!), found this out by using a sophisticated mathematical model.

However, it seems that not only sheep are shrinking because of global warming, other animals as well. Some reports, not yet peer-reviewed, have reported that unicorns are also shrinking. Medieval records put the average length of their horns at 95 centimetres. This is based on the many medieval illustrations of unicorns. I have attached a picture of a unicorn in one of the famous medieval tapestries in the Cluny museum in Paris, titled La Dame à la Licorne (the Lady and the Unicorn). Statistics show that at present the average size of their horns has shrunk to 80 centimetres. These scientists predict that, if we don’t stop global warming, their horns may have disappeared altogether by the end of this century.

More research has to be carried out to find out how serious this global warming threat is. If it is true, people may also start shrinking. The human race could end up as pygmies. But personally I am not too worried. After all, this research was based on computer models, and, as we know from many global-warming-related computer models, the saying “rubbish in, gospel out” is true for most of them.

Sunday, June 21, 2009

Low-lying Pacific islands are not drowning because of rising sea levels

Dear W.A. I am very worried that low-lying Pacific islands will soon disappear because of rising sea-levels caused by carbon dioxide emisssions? Signed: Friend of Tuvalu

Dear Friend of Tuvalu - Don’t. It ain’t so. Environmental groups like Greenpeace like to show pictures of Pacific islands being inundated by sea water, blaming it on sea level rise caused by man-made carbon dioxide emissions. But the story is not that simple. Recently, on May 3, New Zealand TV broadcast a program round the launch of a global warming book POLES APART, by economist Gareth Morgan and writer John McCrystal. They showed sea water sloshing through a village on Takuu island, situated about 250 km north-east of Bougainville. The story was that rising sea levels were drowning the island and that its inhabitants would soon have to be evacuated. They would then become the first global warming refugees. Searching the Internet, I found that the sea level is rising by a huge 20 cm per year. I also found information that the island is SINKING, because of its position on the Pacific tectonic plate that is being subducted into the Solomon Trench. Plate tectonics is causing the island to disappear below the waves, not human carbon dioxide emissions. Some people criticised the TV program, pointing this out. A discussion developed in blogosphere, some people maintaining that it was global warming, not plate tectonics . These people are not susceptible to simple logic. If the sea is rising by 20 cm per year (that is 20 metres by the end of this century!!), it should also be noticed in other Pacific islands. Fortunately, we can check with the Australian South Pacific Sea Level & Climate Monitoring Project (www.bom.gov.au/pacificsealevel/). They have twelve monitoring stations over a wide area around Takuu. Their Figure 11 shows monthly mean sea levels from 1992 to March 2009. Most show variations over time but no overall rise, not even in Tuvalu, the poster island for the global warming alarmists. From this can be concluded that the sea level rise of 20 cm per year in Takuu is mainly caused by a sinking tectonic plate.
Incidentally, the IPCC, in its 2007 Fourth Assessment Report, has projections (NOT predictions!) for global sea level rise by the end of this century of between 18 and 59 centimetres only.
But real-world data will not deter global warming alarmists. If one search for Takuu on Google Earth, it shows a nearby island group to the west, called Carteret Islands. These islands are on the same sinking tectonic plate as Takuu. It has the Greenpeace G-logo next to it. Clicking on it brings up the following text:
The Carteret Islands, off the coast of Papua New Guinea, could be one of the first casualty communities as a result of climate change related sea level rise. This idyllic South Pacific paradise is suffering from the combined effects of sea level rise, erosion, storm surges, increased population and increased salinity of the soil. The combined effect are making the Carteret Islands uninhabitable.
No mention of tectonic plates of course. This blatant dishonesty is typical for groups like Greenpeace. Anything to scare the living daylight out of the unsuspecting public. All we can say is: DON’T WORRY. IT AIN’T SO

Monday, June 1, 2009

Carbon dioxide levels already above 350 ppmv


Dear W.A. I can’t sleep, because I am scared witless that carbon dioxide (CO2) levels in the atmosphere are already above 350 ppmv and may increase further, ending in catastrophe. Signed: Scared Witless.

Dear Scared Witless - Don’t be! The belief that CO2 levels in the atmosphere above 350 ppmv (part per million by volume) are dangerous is pure fantasy, not based on any scientific evidence whatsoever. That figure is just plucked out of the hat for ideological- environmental reasons.
Global warming fundamentalists are afraid that no new draconian international climate treaty to replace the Kyoto Protocol will emerge from the December UN climate conference in Copenhagen. They have started a world-wide action, based on the mythical number 350. They have created a website to promote their action, called 350.org. Their aim is to have world-wide demonstrations on October 24 to try to force political delegates to the Copenhagen conference to pass an economically devastating treaty to drastically reduce CO2 emissions. There is no scientific evidence that human CO2 emissions are causing, or will cause catastrophic global warming. Such evidence that there may be is purely based on non-validated computer models. But the 350 activists are hell-bent to push through a treaty to reduce emissions anyhow, through world-wide demonstrations. We call these activists therefore climate extremists. One has to wonder why these people obtain satisfaction in scaring little children and elderly ladies with unfounded myths.
We feel that Warmaholics Anonymous will become very important, to reduce anxieties, in the coming months, leading up to the Copenhagen conference. Climate fundamentalists will pull out all stops to realise their dangerous fantasies. We will try, in our small way, to counter that. In coming A.A. blogs, we will use the scare arguments of the 350 extremists to tell you that
It Ain’t So.